For pharmaceutical proteins,peptide mapping has two primary purposes:it is a highly specific identity method and,in the case of biotechnology-derived products,may serve as a confirmation of genetic stability.Peptide mapping is used to compare the protein structure of a specific lot of material to that of a suitable reference material/reference standard or to those structures of previous lots to confirm correctness of the primary structure and to confirm lot-to-lot consistency of primary structure (within the limits of this technique).The amino-and carboxy-terminal peptides and carbohydrate-containing peptides often can be separated and identified.The latter are valuable in the peptide maps of glycosylated proteins such as monoclonal antibodies.Peptide mapping may be used to determine the presence of single or multiple incorrect amino acids that may result from such events as a single point mutation or mistranslation of the cDNAsequence.

The procedure involves the selective fragmentation of the protein into discrete peptides that are resolved by some chromatographic technique.The fragmentation is accomplished with endoproteases,such as trypsin,chymotrypsin,thermolysin,or V8protease,or by selective chemical degradation with cyanogen bromide,which cleaves at specific sites on the molecule.Selection of the appropriate endoprotease to be used is directed by the primary sequence of the protein.Trypsin cleaves on the C-terminal side of the basic residues lysine and arginine;chymotrypsin cleaves after the aromatic residues phenylalanine,tyrosine,and tryptophan;thermolysin cleaves after the hydrophobic residues leucine,isoleucine,and valine;V8protease cleaves after the acidic residues glutamic acid and aspartic acid;and cyanogen bromide cleaves at methionyl residues.Other enzymes,such as clostripain (arginine)and endoproteinase lys-C(lysine),and chemical methods,such as 2-nitro-5-thiocyanobenzoic acid (cysteine),may also be used.Each of these methods has its own set of advantages and disadvantages.One common disadvantage to all these techniques is that nonspecific cleavages occur to some degree.It is important that the peptides generated from the digestion are large enough to provide structural information about the protein,and yet small enough to allow their analysis and separation by a technique such as RP-HPLC.For this reason and the fact that cleavage with this enzyme is almost quantitative,trypsin is the enzyme with the most general applicability for most proteins.For large proteins of greater than 60,000daltons (about 520amino acids),cleavage with trypsin may result in too many fragments,so another endoprotease may be chosen.L-TPCK(tosyl-L-phenylalanine chloromethyl ketone)-treated trypsin normally is used because TPCKinhibits the action of chymotrypsin,a contaminant present in many trypsin preparations.Although reaction with cyanogen bromide cleaves at methionyl residues,proteins do not contain many of these residues.As a result,relatively few peptides are obtained and these may be too large or hydrophobic for HPLCseparation.

Once the digestion is complete,the peptides are generally separated by either RP-HPLCand/or HPIEC.Selection of the appropriate column is empirically based and will vary for different proteins.For RP-HPLC,both 100-Åand 300-Åpore size supports work well,and the selection of the silica support may be an important criterion for optimal separation.For the smaller peptides generated by these digestions,C8and C18stationary phases generally have been found to be more efficient than C4supports.The most common solvents used for reversed-phase separations are water and acetonitrile containing a constant (~0.1%)amount of trifluoroacetic acid.Buffered mobile phases containing phosphate also offer excellent selectivity depending on the pH.Screening the effect of pHin the 3.0to 5.0range causes a shift of peptides containing the acidic residues,glutamic acid and aspartic acid.For ion-exchange separations,less information is available,but both silica and polymeric supports with both weak and strong ion-exchange stationary support can be used successfully.Because many of the peptides are somewhat hydrophobic,the addition of small amounts of organic solvents in the mobile phase,such as 5%to 10%methanol or acetonitrile,may be necessary.Apotential disadvantage of HPIECanalysis of peptide mixtures is that sometimes neutral peptides or peptides that have the same charge as the support may not be retained on the column and thus may not be separated or identified by this method.

Immunoassays are used either as active drug substance methods to identify and quantitate the protein of interest or as impurity profile methods to detect and quantitate known host cell protein impurities.Because these protein impurities may represent a large number of potential impurities at trace levels rather than a single impurity,the immunoassays must be sensitive and selective to detect as many of these impurities as possible.Immunoassays that can measure these impurities to very low levels have been developed for E.coliproteins (ECPs)and CHOproteins.Immunoassays additionally may serve as potency assays for monoclonal antibodies using an appropriate antigen.

Immunoassays consist of a large group of assays that depend on specific high-affinity antibody:antigen interactions.These assays include the radioimmunoassays (RIAs)and the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs).RIAs are performed in a liquid or solid phase using an unlabeled antibody directed against the radiolabeled protein of interest.The principle of the RIAis that the inhibition of binding of labeled antigen to unlabeled antibody by samples is compared to the inhibition by known standards,thus allowing quantitation of the protein of interest.

Immunoradiometric assays (IRMAs)or sandwich RIAs employ two antibody preparations that are used to sandwich the protein of interest.The first antibody is unlabeled and is directed against the protein,and the second antibody is radiolabeled and may be directed against the protein or the first antibody.The entire antibody:antigen complex is isolated and the amount of radioactivity,and,therefore,the protein of interest,is determined.The development of an RIAor IRMAfor a biotechnology-derived product requires careful attention to production of the antisera,preparation of the labeled tracer,preparation of a suitable reference standard,and methods for the separation of free antigen from bound antigen.

The most commonly used ELISAformat of trace impurity analysis is the sandwich ELISAthat utilizes two antibody preparations like the IRMA,but without radiolabeling.The first antibody is unlabeled and the second antibody has an enzyme such as horseradish peroxidase (HRP)or alkaline phosphatase attached.Basically,the ELISAmethod consists of applying a layer of purified antibodies to the host cell proteins onto microtitration plates,followed by the protein product.The enzyme antibody conjugate is added and allowed to bind to the antibody-bound host cell proteins.An appropriate substrate is added for color development,which is analyzed with a spectrophotometric plate reader.Such a multiantigen ELISArequires a representative reference standard preparation of appropriate host cell protein impurities to serve as the immunogen for preparation of the antibodies used for the assay.This reference standard preparation is usually prepared from a manufacturing production run yielding all of the expected host cell proteins except the product protein.The total absence of the product protein is necessary in this preparation to avoid the production of antibodies to the product itself when the reference standard is used as an immunogen.Because of varying affinities of polyclonal antibodies to multiantigen preparations,the absolute accuracy of the multiantigen methods and the ability to detect every potential antigen cannot be guaranteed.

Electrophoretic assays are among the most common and powerful of the assays used to evaluate protein purity and homogeneity.They are valuable not only for the initial evaluation and release of biotechnology-derived products but also as stability-indicating methods for detecting molecular or chemical changes in the molecule as a result of denaturation,aggregation,oxidation,deamidation,etc.The use of these methods is facilitated by their simplicity and their requirement of only microgram quantities of sample.The two types of electrophoretic assays most often used for biotechnology-derived products are sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE)and isoelectric focusing (IEF).

The SDS-PAGEmethod separates proteins primarily by their molecular weight because,in the presence of the anionic detergent SDS,a net negatively charged protein SDScomplex is formed.The sample is first denatured in the detergent,which disrupts the noncovalent intramolecular and intermolecular bonds that hold proteins together,and then it is electrophoresed through a polyacrylamide gel support.Protein migration through the gel is proportional to size so that smaller proteins migrate faster through the gel than larger ones.Samples are often electrophoresed under both reduced and nonreduced conditions to determine if impurities of the same molecular weight or if intramolecular proteolytic cleavages of the protein of interest are present.Although nonreducing SDS-PAGEis commonly used to estimate the state of aggregation and/or oligomerization of the protein of interest,this method will only permit observation of aggregates or oligomers that are stable in the presence of SDSand the conditions used for sample preparation and electrophoresis.Proteins consisting of multiple chains held together by disulfide bonds are broken down and separated into their individual polypeptide chains.Sample detection following electrophoresis can be quantitative with densitometric analysis of Coomassie Brilliant Blue stain or qualitative,but with increased sensitivity in the nanogram range,with silver stain.Silver stain SDS-PAGEmay also be performed quantitatively under suitable conditions.With proper validation,Coomassie Brilliant Blue staining and densitometry may also be used to give quantitative determination of polypeptides in the nanogram range.SDS-PAGEcoupled with Coomassie Brilliant Blue stain is used to quantitatively determine the purity of the sample with regard to dimer and larger covalent aggregates and fragments.When the method is combined with the silver stain technique,an assessment of low/trace levels of a new impurity can be made by directly comparing the electrophoresed sample to the electrophoresed reference material or standard under reduced and nonreduced conditions.Generally,silver staining is used qualitatively because of potential major variations in binding of silver from protein to protein,and relatively inconsistent background on a routine basis.An estimation of the quantity of an impurity can be obtained by electrophoresis of a known amount of an internal standard such as bovine serum albumin or lesser dilutions of the protein of interest on other lanes of the same gel.The SDS-PAGEseparation of a protein can be combined with an immunological method such as immunoblotting.The resulting Western blot is used to determine the identity of an electrophoretic band (i.e.,product related or host cell protein impurity).After electrophoresis,the separated proteins are transferred onto a nitrocellulose or polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF)membrane and reacted with the antibody of interest.Visualization of the complex is done with an enzymatically or radiolabeled antibody.

The IEFmethod separates proteins on the basis of their charge in an electrical field.The charges on a protein originate from various sources within its amino acid composition,such as protonated amino groups,unprotonated carboxyl groups,deprotonated sulfhydryl groups or tyrosine residues,oxidized cysteine residues,and deamidated residues.However,for each protein there is a pHat which the protein is isoelectric and these charges cancel each other,with the net charge being effectively zero.IEFis performed in the native state in a support of loose-pore polyacrylamide or agarose gel containing ampholytes (amphoteric low molecular weight ions)that set up a pHgradient because of their migration within the support matrix when an electrical field is applied.Simultaneously,in the presence of the electrical field,positively charged proteins migrate towards the cathode and negatively charged proteins migrate towards the anode.Migration stops when each protein reaches the pHvalue in the support gradient where its net charge is zero.This is the apparent pIor isoelectric point of the protein.Because the migration of a protein is dependent on its amino acid composition,altered forms of the protein and other proteins will migrate to different points on the support.IEFgels may be stained for protein visualization with either Coomassie Brilliant Blue or silver stains.IEFis employed as an identity tool or to ensure the homogeneity of a protein (e.g.,monoclonal antibodies)as demonstrated by a banding pattern with the correct pIrange.The method can also be used to evaluate the stability of a biological product.Protein deamidation (i.e.,glutamine or asparagine residue deamidation)over time leading to the production of a new carboxylic acid group results in molecules with a more acidic pI.IEFcan provide information on the state of glycosylation of glycoproteins such as monoclonal antibodies,which may appear as many bands because of changes in the apparent charge on the protein molecule as a result of the sialic acid residues.IEFgel patterns are usually more complicated to interpret than those of SDS-PAGEand interpretation may require many assumptions or subjective judgment.

High-performance capillary electrophoresis (HPCE),which offers the potential advantages of very high protein resolution,is being thoroughly investigated because of recent advances in the technology.

Chromatographic methods have long been used in the determination of the purity of small organic molecules and proteins such as insulin (see Chromatography á621ñ)and in the determination of the active ingredient and/or excipient concentration of pharmaceutical products.Chromatographic methods are also very effective in the determination of the purity of recombinant pharmaceuticals.However,the chromatography of proteins is far more difficult because of multiple modes of interaction with the chromatographic support as a result of the size and/or shape,charge,and hydrophobicity of the proteins.The most common chromatographic methods used to profile recombinant proteins are RP-HPLC,HPIEC,size-exclusion chromatography (HPSEC),and hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC).These methods involve the separation of proteins and are used to determine the purity of drug substances as well as the levels of known impurities or degradation products.Acomplication with all column chromatographic methods is determining the mass balance between column load and column eluate.Nevertheless,HPLCtechniques are valuable for determining the purity and strength of protein pharmaceuticals.

The most common RP-HPLCanalyses are performed on columns containing a C4or C8stationary phase on a silica-based or polymeric support.C18stationary phases are also used but more often with smaller peptides in an application such as peptide mapping.Supports with pore sizes of at least 300Åare preferred for proteins of molecular weight greater than about 10,000.For most RP-HPLCanalyses,the proteins are eluted with aqueous acetonitrile gradients and the trifluoroacetic acid is kept constant at 0.1%.Other buffers such as phosphate or tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane (Tris)are also used,where the pHmay be adjusted for added selectivity to achieve optimal separations.

HPIECis an important method for purity determination.These separations are based on changes in the charge of the molecule and are useful for identifying and quantitating in protein pharmaceuticals common impurities such as oxidized (primarily oxidized methionine)and deamidated forms (glutamine and asparagine)and clipped or truncated forms.Both strong and weak ion-exchange stationary phases on either silica or polymeric supports can be used.Cation-exchange chromatography may be performed on sulfopropyl-type resins and are effective in distinguishing oxidation and deamidation products.Proteins are typically loaded onto a column equilibrated with water or a weak buffer,and eluted with a salt gradient,such as 0to 1Msodium chloride.

HPSECis a technique that may provide information on the levels of aggregation and fragmentation in a protein pharmaceutical.Depending on the information needed,the mobile phase may be native,containing an aqueous buffer such as 100mMphosphate,pH7,or it may be denaturing,containing a low level of a chaotrope or detergent such as 0.1%SDS.The analyses are performed isocratically,with detection typically between 210and 220nm depending on the buffer used.Detection at 280nm may also be used but is less sensitive.Classical size-exclusion chromatography was performed on soft polymeric supports such as cross-linked dextrans,polyacrylamide,or agarose.These,however,are better suited for low-pressure applications.As a result,a number of supports with increased mechanical strength have been developed.Commercially available silica-based and cross-linked agarose supports are now commonly used.HPSECis also useful for the determination of clipped forms of proteins.Clipped chains often remain attached through the disulfide bonds of cysteine residues.Treatment of the sample with a reducing agent such as dithiothreitol or mercaptoethanol will cleave the disulfide bond and separate the chains.The clipped chains may then be resolved from unclipped forms by HPSEC.

HICprovides separation of proteins based on differences in their hydrophobicity under mild adsorption and elution conditions that generally prevent denaturation and subsequent loss of biological activity.Astationary phase that is weakly hydrophobic is used with a buffered aqueous mobile phase and an initial high-salt concentration to adsorb the protein,which is then selectively eluted using a decreasing salt gradient.Interactions occur between nonpolar amino acid residues that are exposed on the surface of the protein and hydrophobic groups that are present on the chromatographic matrix.Anumber of silica-based and polymeric supports combined with weakly hydrophobic ligands,such as polyethers,phenyl ethers,or short alkyl chains,have been developed for use in HIC.This technique can be used in the analysis,purification,and characterization of more labile hydrophobic proteins.Protein retention and selectivity can be modified by control of variables such as salt type and concentration,pHand selective-ion effects,temperature and gradient design,as well as by careful selection of the stationary phase.

Biomimetic assays (assays that mimic the biological effect of the product)are of major significance in the discussion of assays for biotechnology-derived products.These assays measure the activity of the product and ensure that it is efficacious.Essentially,there are three major types of quantitative assays:animal model assays,cell culture-based assays and in-vitro (physicochemical)assays.Each of these assays has application in the control of biological products.Regardless of the type of quantitative assay employed,it is desirable and,in some cases,necessary,to use a biomimetic assay.

Residual host cell DNAis a potential process-specific impurity in a biotechnology-derived product.The residual DNAis unique for each product because it is dependent on the host organism and the process recovery procedure used to manufacture the product.Although adverse health effects have not been reported from biologicals because of their DNAcontent,regulatory agencies have requested manufacturers to ensure that the DNAlevel in biotechnology-derived products is reduced to low levels.

The technique of DNAhybridization (dot blot analysis)is the most sensitive,routine DNAassay available to determine the DNAcontent of products.It is valuable as a purification process assay to demonstrate that a low level of DNAhas been attained early in the manufacturing process.The method relies on the hybridization of cellular DNAfrom the sample with either specific 32P-labeled or chemically modified DNAprobes obtained from the DNAof the host cell.The analysis is performed by first isolating any residual DNAin the sample by a procedure that may include hydrolysis of the protein,chromatography,organic extractions,and alcohol precipitation.The isolated DNAis denatured and then applied to a nitrocellulose or nylon membrane along with a set of serially-diluted host DNAstandards.Positive and negative DNAcontrols are also applied and the membrane may be baked at approximately 80or placed under UVlight to complete binding of the DNAto the membrane.A DNAprobe is then prepared either by nick translation,random primer synthesis,or chemical modification of a DNAextract of the host cell.The DNAprobe is purified and thermally denatured at 95.It is then added to the baked or UV-treated membrane and allowed to hybridize with the DNAof the samples at approximately 42in the presence of formamide or at higher temperatures without formamide for 24to 48hours.The membrane is subsequently placed between two X-ray films and exposed to produce an autoradiograph or is developed by immunochemical means using an enzyme conjugate/substrate system similar to ELISAand/or Western blot.The DNAof the sample is estimated by visual comparison of the dot intensity of the sample to those of the diluted DNAstandards.The autoradiogram can also be scanned by optical densitometry.The sensitivity of the assay,i.e.,10to 250pg,is determined by the limit of visual detection above background of the serially-diluted DNAstandards.

Other methods for DNAdetermination have been developed using biosensor technology.This methodology currently determines total DNA/nucleic acid impurities rather than specific host cell DNA.This technology may become quite valuable in the future,especially when more specific DNAbinding methods are developed.Finally,the recently developed polymerase chain reaction (PCR)technology,which involves DNAamplification,may prove useful in detection and identification of contaminant DNA.Quantitative use of this technology,however,will require further development.

One of the possible post-translational modifications that occurs on proteins is the covalent attachment of oligosaccharide chains.Glycosylation is a characteristic of recombinant proteins that are expressed from eukaryotic cell lines.Although the polypeptide chain of a glycoprotein is synthesized under the direct control of the genetic code,oligosaccharides are not primary gene products,but are synthesized by enzymes known as glycosyltransferases.This synthesis results in microheterogeneity of the carbohydrate chains.Also,glycosylation is cell-line dependent,so glycoproteins with identical polypeptide chains made in different cell lines may have considerably different carbohydrate structures.The sugars commonly found in glycoproteins include neutral sugars (D-galactose,D-mannose,and L-fucose),amino sugars (N-acetylglucosamine and N-acetylgalactosamine),and the acidic sugar,sialic acid.

Two main approaches can be taken to determine the sugars covalently attached to the glycoprotein.Both are based on the understanding that microheterogeneity is a common phenomenon among glycoproteins,and that the information represents either average composition or representative structures.

The first approach is the determination of the composition of sugars in a glycoprotein,which can be performed by several methods.Neutral sugars and sialic acid may be determined by simple colorimetric tests.Total neutral sugars can be determined following reaction with phenol and sulfuric acid and measuring the absorbance of the solution at about 490nm compared to a standard curve.Following mild acid hydrolysis and periodate oxidation,free sialic acid content can be determined with thiobarbituric acid and the absorbance of the solution at about 550nm compared to a standard curve.Individual neutral sugars can be determined following acid hydrolysis by several methods.Underivatized,they can be separated by HPIECat high pHand quantitated by pulsed amperometric detection.They may also be converted to the alditol peracetates with acetic anhydride or to the aldononitrile acetates with hydroxylamine hydrochloride and pyridine prior to peracetylation,and the derivatives separated by gas chromatography.

The second approach in determining the carbohydrate composition is to release and separate individual oligosaccharide structures covalently attached to the glycoprotein.This requires an understanding of the types of structures attached.The attachment of sugars to proteins can occur in two major ways:through an O-glycosidic bond involving the hydroxyl group of serine,threonine,or modified amino acids such as hydroxylysine or hydroxyproline,or through the N-glycosidic bond of asparagine.O-linked oligosaccharides can be released from the protein following beta-elimination under alkaline conditions and reduction of the reducing end sugar with sodium borohydride.N-linked oligosaccharides can be released chemically by hydrazinolysis or enzymatically by one of a variety of specific glycosidases,such as endo H,endo F,or peptido-N-glycanase.The oligosaccharides can then be separated by HPIECat high pHand quantitated with pulsed amperometric detection.This results in an oligosaccharide or carbohydrate map analogous to the peptide map for the protein.

Specific assays pertaining to biotechnology focus on the detection of bacteria,fungi,mycoplasma,and viruses.These reflect the possible contaminants that may occur in both bacterial fermentation and mammalian cell culture.Control is exerted in a variety of ways including characterization of the master seed bank and the working cell banks to ensure freedom from these contaminants,evaluation of raw materials,the design and operation of closed manufacturing systems,testing of production lots,and validation of specific manufacturing processes to ensure that contaminants would be inactivated or removed if present.

Freedom of final sterile dosage forms from bacteria and fungi is usually evaluated by tests for sterility as described in Sterility Tests á71ñ.Mycoplasma assays are performed by standard cultivation methods employing aerobic and anaerobic incubation of solid medium in plates and semisolid broth in tubes and must comply with the code of federal regulations (21CFR610.12).In addition,noncultivable mycoplasma are detected microscopically by using the Hoechst bisbenzimide staining method.

Various methods that are used for the detection of adventitious virus contamination in cell lines include inoculation of indicator cell lines selected for their ability to support the replication of a broad range of viruses and monitoring these for markers of virus infection such as cytopathology,hemadsorption,hemagglutination,and immunofluorescence;inoculation of intact animals and monitoring for illness and death;inoculation of animals and,after four weeks,collection and evaluation of serum for antibodies to specific viruses of concern;and specific immunologic assays or genetic probes for some viruses of concern that cannot be detected by the other methods listed.

The expression of endogenous retrovirus genes is highly variable among different mammalian cells and cell lines.The unpredictable nature of their expression and the diversity of their biochemical and biological properties preclude the use of a single test and instead require an integrated testing strategy.Test methods generally used include transmission electron microscopy of cells from the master seed bank and ultracentrifuged pellets of cell-free,cell culture harvests;various assays for infectious retroviruses that use retrovirus-susceptible indicator cell lines;reverse transcriptase activity;and induction of retroviruses in cells of the master cell bank with chemicals known to induce retroviruses.In addition to classical virological methods,newer techniques such as molecular probe hybridization are also beginning to be used for these evaluations.